2D week 6

My 2 designs for the BLOX logo, for a non profit organization and one to be used in the industry

 

i like my 2 designs, the industry one looks very futuristic and industrial-like, so it goes well if it were to be used for a industry, also the tag line matches the theme and look of the design.
the non-profit one is suppose to look like blox, like in tetras that fall into place, thats why the tag line is "where things fall in place". if the color of it was more brown it would look like falling bricks, which will help the theme.

my other 2 starting designs, before refined in illustrator

group ratings on everyone's designs. ( doesnt have everyone else's ratings)

Carol – design industry

1. Accuracy in addressing the brief - 7, 6, 6, 6, 6 = 6.2

2. Immediate visual appeal – 5, 6, 4, 4, 10 = 5.8

3. Cross generational appeal – 4, 4, 2, 3, 7 = 4

4. Suitability for print – 3, 5, 6, 5, 8 = 5.4

5. Suitability for web – 8, 7, 10, 6, 10 = 8.2

6. Monochromatic suitability – 0, 3, 3, 1, 5 = 2.4

7. Simplicity – 4, 4, 1, 2, 5 = 3.2

Carol – non profit

1. Accuracy in addressing the brief - 6

2. Immediate visual appeal - 6

3. Cross generational appeal - 6

4. Suitability for print - 7

5. Suitability for web - 7

6. Monochromatic suitability - 4

7. Simplicity - 5

Sarah – design industry

1. Accuracy in addressing the brief - 9

2. Immediate visual appeal - 9

3. Cross generational appeal - 8

4. Suitability for print - 10

5. Suitability for web - 10

6. Monochromatic suitability - 10

7. Simplicity - 10

Sarah – non profit

1. Accuracy in addressing the brief - 9

2. Immediate visual appeal - 9

3. Cross generational appeal - 8

4. Suitability for print - 10

5. Suitability for web - 10

6. Monochromatic suitability - 9

7. Simplicity - 8

Stevie – design industry

1. Accuracy in addressing the brief - 8

2. Immediate visual appeal - 9

3. Cross generational appeal - 7

4. Suitability for print - 10

5. Suitability for web - 9

6. Monochromatic suitability - 7

7. Simplicity - 8

Stevie – non profit 

1. Accuracy in addressing the brief - 8

2. Immediate visual appeal - 10

3. Cross generational appeal - 9

4. Suitability for print - 10

5. Suitability for web - 9

6. Monochromatic suitability - 6

7. Simplicity - 9

Teddy – design industry

1. Accuracy in addressing the brief - 7

2. Immediate visual appeal - 7

3. Cross generational appeal - 7

4. Suitability for print - 10

5. Suitability for web - 10

6. Monochromatic suitability - 9

7. Simplicity - 8

Teddy– non profit

1. Accuracy in addressing the brief - 9

2. Immediate visual appeal - 7

3. Cross generational appeal - 6

4. Suitability for print - 10

5. Suitability for web - 9

6. Monochromatic suitability - 9

7. Simplicity - 8

Zac – design industry

1. Accuracy in addressing the brief - 8

2. Immediate visual appeal - 9

3. Cross generational appeal - 8

4. Suitability for print - 10

5. Suitability for web - 10

6. Monochromatic suitability - 8

7. Simplicity - 8

Zac – non profit

1. Accuracy in addressing the brief - 10

2. Immediate visual appeal - 7

3. Cross generational appeal - 6

4. Suitability for print - 10

5. Suitability for web - 9

6. Monochromatic suitability - 10

7. Simplicity - 9